← Latest briefing

US News

Studies disagree on whether school phone bans improve student test scores

A Harvard-led study of 3.3 million students found modest gains from strict phone limits, while a separate NBER study found close to zero effect.

The short version

  • More than 40 U.S. states have passed school cellphone restrictions, though enforcement varies and some bans are weakly applied.[Associated Press]
  • A Harvard-led study found strict bans linked to modest academic growth, estimated at one or two extra weeks of learning per year.[Associated Press]
  • A separate National Bureau of Economic Research study published in May concluded strict bans had close to zero effect on test scores.[ABC News]
  • Stanford economist Thomas Dee called early results largely disappointing, while Harvard's Thomas Kane said bans help but are not a panacea.[Associated Press · ABC News]

Key facts

  • More than 40 U.S. states have passed laws restricting cellphones at schools, according to the Phone Free Schools State Report Card.[Associated Press]
  • The Harvard-led study analyzed test scores of 3.3 million students at 4,600 schools and estimated gains of about one to two extra weeks of learning per year.[Associated Press]
  • The National Bureau of Economic Research study, published in May, concluded strict school phone bans had close to zero effect on test scores.[ABC News]
  • Harvard professor Thomas Kane said phone bans have a positive effect on growth but are not a panacea.[Associated Press]
  • Stanford economist Thomas Dee said early results from school phone bans are largely disappointing and raise unresolved questions.[ABC News]

What remains uncertain

  • The Harvard and NBER findings conflict, and it remains unresolved why the studies reach different conclusions about test score effects.[Associated Press · ABC News]
  • Enforcement is uneven, and psychologist Jean Twenge said some bans are largely cosmetic, with students at some schools keeping phones in backpacks.[Associated Press]

Sources

Outlet counts describe coverage, not independent confirmation. Reports may share a wire service or original source.