Politics
Former Commerce officials allege chaos and enforcement lapses under Lutnick
CBS News reports that four anonymous former Commerce officials allege failures to act on AI chip smuggling evidence under Secretary Howard Lutnick.
The short version
- Four anonymous former Commerce officials told CBS News that Secretary Howard Lutnick's tenure involved chaos, micromanaging, and failures to act on chip smuggling evidence.[CBS News]
- One former employee said the department could not add entities to the Entity List, and Federal Register records show no additions since October 9, 2025.[CBS News]
- Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told CNBC that Lutnick failed to follow through on chip ban enforcement backed by Treasury and the State Department.[CBS News]
- Former officials said up to 50 skilled staff left over 18 months, but the accounts rest on anonymous sources and the reporting does not establish why the list stalled.[CBS News]
Key facts
- Four anonymous former Commerce officials spoke with CBS News about concerns over export enforcement.[CBS News]
- Federal Register records show the last addition to the Entity List was on October 9, 2025, and the last yearlong gap in additions was in 2008.[CBS News]
- Former officials said subsequent changes under Lutnick helped prompt an exodus of up to 50 skilled staff members over the past 18 months.[CBS News]
- Reuters first reported the February 2025 departures of Matthew Borman and Eileen Albanese, the same month Lutnick began running the department.[CBS News]
- An April 2026 study by the AI research nonprofit Epoch estimated that 290,000 to 1.6 million cutting-edge AI chips were smuggled into China in 2024 and 2025.[CBS News]
- Key roles remain vacant in the Bureau of Industry and Security, according to a registry of current senior federal employees.[CBS News]
- Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told CNBC that Lutnick failed to follow through on chip ban enforcement supported by Treasury, the State Department and others.[CBS News]
What remains uncertain
- The allegations come from four anonymous former officials whose identities and accounts are not independently confirmed in the reporting.[CBS News]
- The Information reported that at least $7.5 billion in Nvidia chips allegedly reached Chinese companies since 2023 through companies linked to Alice Huang; this figure is an allegation.[CBS News]
- The Epoch smuggling figure is an estimate given as a wide range, not a confirmed count.[CBS News]
- The reasons for the stalled Entity List additions and any link to the staff departures are not established in the reporting.[CBS News]
Sources
Outlet counts describe coverage, not independent confirmation. Reports may share a wire service or original source.
- Ex-staffers claim lack of enforcement, "chaos" under LutnickCBS News - Top Stories