US News
Success Academy sues New York education commissioner over blocked AP data
The charter network alleges First Amendment violations after the state withheld exam data from national rankings.
The short version
- Success Academy filed a federal First Amendment lawsuit against New York State Education Commissioner Betty A. Rosa over the state's refusal to authorize the release of 2026 AP exam results to U.S. News & World Report.[Fox News]
- Without the AP data, rankings relied solely on International Baccalaureate metrics, dropping Success Academy's statewide position from 11th to 196th.[Fox News]
- The New York State Education Department cited student data privacy laws, asserting that student records should not be commercialized for ranking products.[Fox News]
- Success Academy alleged the policy suppresses truthful performance metrics to favor traditional public schools over charter schools.[Fox News]
Key facts
- Success Academy initiated a federal First Amendment lawsuit against NYSED Commissioner Betty A. Rosa regarding withheld AP exam results.[Fox News]
- Success Academy's high school rank dropped from 11th to 196th in New York after rankings used only International Baccalaureate data.[Fox News]
- NYSED justified the restriction by stating that student privacy laws prohibit commercializing records for school ranking products.[Fox News]
- Success Academy claimed that 95% of its 2026 graduating class passed three or more AP exams.[Fox News]
What remains uncertain
- The legal validity of NYSED's privacy defense against the First Amendment claims has not yet been ruled on by the federal court.[Fox News]
Sources
Outlet counts describe coverage, not independent confirmation. Reports may share a wire service or original source.
- Charter school network files First Amendment lawsuit after state blocks AP scores from US NewsFox News · Wire: associated-press