← Latest briefing

Politics

Federal judge blocks Trump administration's revised order restricting birthright citizenship

A Maryland federal judge ruled the August executive order likely violates the 14th Amendment and contradicts Supreme Court precedent.

The short version

  • U.S. District Judge Deborah L. Boardman issued a preliminary injunction halting President Donald Trump's August executive order restricting birthright citizenship.
  • The blocked order targeted children of parents classified as "alien enemies," foreign embassy personnel, and individuals tied to "birth tourism."
  • Judge Boardman determined the plaintiffs are likely to succeed on the merits, pointing to a June Supreme Court ruling that upheld 14th Amendment birthright protections.
  • The preliminary injunction remains in place while the underlying class-action lawsuit proceeds through federal court.

Key facts

  • U.S. District Judge Deborah L. Boardman granted a preliminary injunction blocking the enforcement of President Donald Trump's August 6 executive order on birthright citizenship.[Associated Press · CBS News · Al Jazeera · NBC News]
  • The executive order sought to deny citizenship to children born to foreign embassy workers, parents designated as "alien enemies," and individuals engaging in commercial transactions for "birth tourism."[Associated Press · CBS News · Al Jazeera · NBC News]
  • The legal challenge was brought by immigrant families alongside advocacy groups including We Are CASA, the Asylum Seeker Advocacy Project, and the Institute for Constitutional Advocacy and Protection.[Associated Press · CBS News · Al Jazeera · NBC News]
  • Judge Boardman cited the Supreme Court's 6-3 June ruling in Barbara v. Trump, concluding that the new order remains unconstitutional as applied to the certified class.[Associated Press · CBS News · Al Jazeera · NBC News]
  • Justice Department attorneys argued that the injunction request was premature and asserted that prior Supreme Court precedent did not foreclose specific, narrow exceptions to birthright citizenship.[Associated Press · CBS News]

What remains uncertain

  • Whether the administration will appeal the preliminary injunction or how appellate courts will interpret the administration's revised exceptions to birthright citizenship.[Associated Press · CBS News]

Sources